When Tech Companies Do It, The NY Times Calls It ‘Dark Patterns,’; When The NY Times Does It, It’s Called ‘Being Smart’

[ad_1]

from the seems-moderately-hypocritical dept

This post was inspired by a Benedict Evans’ tweet.

One of the many phrases that has become popular to an annoying degree over the last few years is the concept of “dark patterns.” These are, we’re told, sneaky, ethically dubious ways, in which companies — usually “big tech” — trick users into doing what the companies want. I’m not saying that companies don’t do sketchy stuff to try to make money. Lots of companies do. Indeed, we’ve spent decades calling out some pretty sketchy behavior by companies to get your money. But the phrase “dark patterns” has such a connotation to it, and it is now used in cases that, um, don’t even seem that bad (and, yes, I’ve used the term myself, once, but, that was demonstrating specific behavior that was pretty clearly fraudulent).

Of course, the NY Times is among the media orgs which have really popularized the phrase. It wrote one of the earliest popular articles about the concept, and has called it out multiple times when talking about tech companies. That last one is particularly notable because it was written by a member of the NY Times, Greg Bensinger. He really, really doesn’t like “dark patterns” that manipulate users into… say, “signing up for things.”

These are examples of “dark patterns,” the techniques that companies use online to get consumers to sign up for things, keep subscriptions they might otherwise cancel or turn over more personal data. They come in countless variations: giant blinking sign-up buttons, hidden unsubscribe links, red X’s that actually open new pages, countdown timers and pre-checked options for marketing spam. Think of them as the digital equivalent of trying to cancel a gym membership.

He’s pretty sure we need legislation to take down dark patterns.

Companies can’t be expected to reform themselves; they use dark patterns because they work. And while no laws will be able to anticipate or prevent every type of dark pattern, lawmakers can begin to chip away at the imbalance between consumers and corporations by cracking down on these clearly deceptive practices.

Companies can’t be expected to reform themselves.

Anyway. That’s called foreshadowing.

Now, let’s talk about a new piece written by a data scientist at the NY Times, about “how the NY Times uses machine learning to make its paywall smarter.”

The company’s paywall strategy revolves around the concept of the subscription funnel (Figure 1). At the top of the funnel are unregistered users who do not yet have an account with The Times. Once they hit the meter limit for their unregistered status, they are shown a registration wall that blocks access and asks them to make an account with us, or to log in if they already have an account. Doing this gives them access to more free content and, since their activity is now linked to their registration ID, it allows us to better understand their current appetite for Times content. This user information is valuable for any machine learning application and powers the Dynamic Meter as well. Once registered users hit their meter limit, they are served a paywall with a subscription offer. It is this moment that the Dynamic Meter model controls. The model learns from the first-party engagement data of registered users and determines the appropriate meter limit in order to optimize for one or more business K.P.I.s (Key Performance Indicators).

Cool. (And, yes, this is legitimately cool to see how the company handles the meter in a more dynamic way — more companies should be more dynamic like that).

But, um, also, isn’t that… a dark pattern? I mean, it’s not clear to the end user. It’s designed to — and I’ll quote here — “get consumers to sign up for things, keep subscriptions they might otherwise cancel or turn over more personal data.”

The writeup by the data scientist is pretty clear what they’re trying to do here:

Thus, the model must take an action that will affect a user’s behavior and influence the outcome, such as their subscription propensity and engagement with Times content.

I mean, this is all kind of interesting, but… it sure sounds like what the NY Times editorial side is complaining about as a dark pattern.

And that’s where some of the problem with the term comes into play. There’s a spectrum of behavior — some of which is just smart business and tech practices, and some of which is more nefarious. But using the term “dark patterns” to broadly describe anything that we don’t understand, or can’t see that is designed to get you to do something… becomes problematic pretty quickly. I don’t have a problem with the way the NY Times runs its paywall. It’s trying to make it work in a reasonable way that converts more users into subscribers.

Clearly, this is not as nefarious as services that make it impossible to, say, cancel your subscription without first having to talk to a human (oh wait, the NY Times does that too?). Um, okay, it’s not as nefarious as literally tricking people into signing up for recurring payments rather than a one time thing. That’s even worse.

But, it is still a spectrum. And when we refer to any optimization efforts as “dark patterns” then the problematic parts of “dark patterns” lose their meaning. It becomes way too easy to smear perfectly reasonable efforts as somehow nefarious. It’s fine to talk about sketchy things that companies do, but we should be specific about what they are and why they’re sketchy, rather than just assuming anything that is designed to drive conversions is inherently problematic.

The fact that the NY Times on the tech/business side uses exactly what the editorial side condemns in order to be able to pay the editorial side’s salaries, should at least inform the framing of some of this discussion.

Filed Under: conversion rates, dark patterns, optimization, paywalls

Companies: ny times



[ad_2]

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous post Impossible: Dolo 650 manufacturer on Rs 1000 crore marketing budget
Next post Assistant Secretary Robinson’s Travel with ONDCP and USAID Leadership to Colombia
akun-pro-kambojaakun-pro-rusiaakun-pro-jepangakun-pro-malaysiaakun-pro-thailandakun-pro-taiwanakun-pro-myanmarakun-pro-vietnamakun-pro-hongkongakun-pro-filipinaakun-pro-singaporeakun-pro-amerikaakun pro jepangakun pro thailandakun pro rusiaakun pro kambojaakun pro malaysiaakun pro myanmarakun pro taiwanakun pro platinumakun pro taiwan 189akun pro big855slot gacor 88slot gacor 4dslot gacor 777slot kambojaslot thailandslot hongkongslot platinumslot myanmarslot amerikaslot taiwanslot jepangslot malaysiaslot server luarmahjong slotsv388digmaanserver taiwan 105senang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99akun gacorlink gacor situs gacorakun pro amerikaakun pro asiaakun pro chinaakun pro dubaiakun pro filipinaakun pro hongkongakun pro italiaakun pro jepangakun pro jermanakun pro kamboja akun pro koreaakun pro lebanon akun pro londonakun pro malaysiaakun pro myanmarakun pro platinumakun pro prancisakun pro rusia akun pro singaporeakun pro taiwan akun pro thailandakun pro vietnamslot gacor 88slot gacor 4dslot gacor 777slot kambojaslot thailandslot hongkongslot platinumslot myanmarslot amerikaslot taiwanslot jepangslot malaysiaslot server luarmahjong slotsv388digmaanserver taiwan 105senang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99slot server thailand slot server myanmar slot server kamboja slot server jepang slot server filipina slot server hongkong slot server china slot server malaysia slot server taiwan slot server ceko slot server dubai slot server prancis slot server italia slot server swiss slot server inggris slot server amerika senang303 sukses303 horus303 sboku99 amarta99 spesial4d slot777 slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot jerman akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot china slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan akun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro rusiaakun pro thailandakun pro malaysiaakun pro myanmarakun pro platinumakun-pro-hongkongakun pro taiwanakun pro amerikaakun-pro-filipinaakun-pro-koreaakun-pro-prancissenang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99slot gacor 88slot gacor 4dslot gacor 777slot kambojaslot thailandslot hongkongslot platinumslot myanmarslot amerikaslot taiwanslot jepangslot malaysiaslot server luarmahjong slotsv388digmaanserver taiwan 105senang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro singaporeakun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot china slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 amarta99 slot 4d slot idn slot nuke akun pro thailand akun pro myanmar akun pro kamboja akun pro jepang akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro china akun pro malaysia akun pro taiwan akun pro ceko akun pro dubai akun pro prancis akun pro italia akun pro swiss akun pro inggris akun pro amerika senang303 sukses303 horus303 sboku99 amarta99 spesial4d akun gacor link gacor situs gacor slot myanmar slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam slot malaysia slot luar negeri slot luar slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 akun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro rusiaakun pro thailandakun pro malaysiaakun pro myanmarakun pro platinumakun-pro-hongkongakun pro taiwanakun pro amerikaakun-pro-filipinaakun-pro-koreaakun-pro-prancissenang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99slot gacor 88slot gacor 4dslot gacor 777slot kambojaslot thailandslot hongkongslot platinumslot myanmarslot amerikaslot taiwanslot jepangslot malaysiaslot server luarmahjong slotsv388digmaansenang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 amarta99 slot 4d slot idn slot nuke slot server amerikaslot server filipinaslot server hongkongslot server jepangslot server kambojaslot server koreaslot server malaysiaslot server prancisslot server rusiaslot server thailandslot server myanmarslot server vietnamslot server asiaslot server luarakun pro amerikaakun pro filipinaakun pro hongkongakun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro koreaakun pro malaysiaakun pro prancisakun pro rusiaakun pro taiwanakun pro thailandakun pro platinumakun pro singaporeakun pro vietnamamarta99horus303sboku99senang303spesial4dsukses303https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-thailand/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-kamboja/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-jepang/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-rusia/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-hongkong/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-myanmar/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-malaysia/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-filipina/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-taiwan/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-vietnam/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-china/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-amerika/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-prancis/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-lebanon/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-platinum/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-ceko/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-yaman/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-korea/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/akun-pro-jerman/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/senang303/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/sukses303/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/horus303/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/spesial4d/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/sboku99/
https://www.gobatya.com/mesin/amarta99/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-thailand/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-kamboja/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-jepang/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-rusia/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-hongkong/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-myanmar/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-malaysia/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-filipina/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-taiwan/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-vietnam/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-china/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-amerika/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-prancis/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-lebanon/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-platinum/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-ceko/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-yaman/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-korea/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/akun-pro-jerman/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/senang303/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/sukses303/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/horus303/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/spesial4d/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/sboku99/
https://hotelhillknights.com/new/akun/amarta99/slot-server-kambojaslot-server-rusiaslot-server-jepangslot-server-malaysiaslot-server-thailandslot-server-taiwanslot-server-myanmarslot-server-vietnamslot-server-hongkongslot-server-filipinaslot-server-singaporeslot-server-amerikaslot-server-chinaslot-server-turkislot-server-ugandaslot-server-ugandaslot-server-uruguayslot-server-mesirsbobetbola gacor 88slot danano limit citypragmatic slotslot pg softprincess x1000zeus 1000server taiwan 105senang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99server thailand server myanmar server kamboja server jepang server filipina server hongkong server china server malaysia server taiwan server ceko server dubai server prancis server italia server swiss server inggris server amerika senang303 sukses303 horus303 spesial4d sboku99 amarta99 slot luar negeri
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot malaysia
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99slot-server-kambojaslot-server-rusiaslot-server-jepangslot-server-malaysiaslot-server-thailandslot-server-taiwanslot-server-taiwanslot-server-myanmarslot-server-vietnamslot-server-hongkongslot-server-filipinaslot-server-singaporeslot-server-amerikaslot-server-chinaslot-server-turkislot-server-ugandaslot-server-uruguayslot-server-uruguayslot-server-mesirakun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 amarta99 slot 4d slot idn slot nukeakun-pro-kambojaakun-pro-rusiaakun-pro-jepangakun-pro-malaysiaakun-pro-thailandakun-pro-taiwanakun-pro-myanmarakun-pro-vietnamakun-pro-hongkongakun-pro-filipinaakun-pro-singaporeakun-pro-amerikaakun-pro-chinaakun-pro-turkiakun-pro-ugandaakun-pro-uruguayakun-pro-mesirslot server amerikaslot server filipinaslot server hongkongslot server jepangslot server kambojaslot server koreaslot server malaysiaslot server prancisslot server rusiaslot server thailandslot server myanmarslot server vietnamslot server asiaslot server luarakun pro amerikaakun pro filipinaakun pro hongkongakun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro koreaakun pro malaysiaakun pro prancisakun pro rusiaakun pro taiwanakun pro thailandakun pro platinumakun pro singaporeakun pro vietnamakun pro thailand
akun pro kamboja
akun pro jepang
akun pro rusia
akun pro hongkong
akun pro myanmar
akun pro malaysia
akun pro filipina
akun pro taiwan
akun pro vietnam
akun pro china
akun pro amerika
akun pro prancis
akun pro lebanon
akun pro platinum
akun pro ceko
akun pro yaman
akun pro korea
akun pro jermanakun pro thailand
akun pro kamboja
akun pro jepang
akun pro rusia
akun pro hongkong
akun pro myanmar
akun pro malaysia
akun pro filipina
akun pro taiwan
akun pro vietnam
akun pro china
akun pro amerika
akun pro prancis
akun pro lebanon
akun pro platinum
akun pro ceko
akun pro yaman
akun pro korea
akun pro jerman
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 gates of olympus x1000 starlight princes x1000 amarta99 slot 4d slot idn slot nuke akun gacor link gacor situs gacor slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot luar negeri slot luar slot malaysia slot myanmar slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam sbobetbola gacor 88slot danano limit citypragmatic slotslot pg softprincess x1000zeus 1000server taiwan 105senang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99slot server luar
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot malaysia
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
akun pro platinumslot luar negeri
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot malaysia
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
slot singapore
slot prancis
slot korea
slot taiwan
slot dubai
slot eropa
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99
akun pro thailand
akun pro kamboja
akun pro jepang
akun pro rusia
akun pro hongkong
akun pro myanmar
akun pro malaysia
akun pro filipina
akun pro taiwan
akun pro vietnam
akun pro china
akun pro amerika
akun pro prancis
akun pro lebanon
akun pro platinum
akun pro ceko
akun pro yaman
akun pro korea
akun pro jerman
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99akun pro thailand akun pro myanmar akun pro kamboja akun pro jepang akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro china akun pro malaysia akun pro taiwan akun pro ceko akun pro dubai akun pro prancis akun pro italia akun pro swiss akun pro inggris akun pro amerika slot77 slot4d sv388 senang303 sukses303 horus303 spesial4d sboku99 akun gacor maxwin link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 amarta99 slot 4d slot idn slot nuke akun gacor link gacor situs gacor slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot luar slot malaysia slot myanmar slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam live casino 77sv388digmaans128slot luar negeriakun pro jepangakun pro platinumakun pro thailandakun pro kambojaakun pro malaysiaakun pro taiwanakun pro myanmarakun pro vietnamakun pro hongkongakun pro filipinaakun pro amerikasenang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99slot server amerikaslot server filipinaslot server hongkongslot server jepangslot server kambojaslot server koreaslot server malaysiaslot server prancisslot server rusiaslot server thailandslot server myanmarslot server vietnamslot server asiaslot server luarakun pro amerikaakun pro filipinaakun pro hongkongakun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro koreaakun pro malaysiaakun pro prancisakun pro rusiaakun pro taiwanakun pro thailandakun pro platinumakun pro singaporeakun pro vietnamslot gacor 88slot gacor 4dslot gacor 777slot kambojaslot thailandslot hongkongslot platinumslot myanmarslot amerikaslot taiwanslot jepangslot malaysiaslot server luarmahjong slotsv388digmaansenang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99server thailand server myanmar server kamboja server jepang server filipina server hongkong server china server malaysia server taiwan server ceko server dubai server prancis server italia server swiss server inggris server amerika slot77 slot4d sv388 akun gacor link gacor situs gacor slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot luar negeri slot luar slot malaysia slot myanmar slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/slot-luar/
https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/slot-thailand/
https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/slot-kamboja/
https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/slot-filipina/
https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/slot-jepang/
https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/slot-rusia/
https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/slot-malaysia/
https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/slot-macau/
https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/slot-myanmar/
https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/slot-vietnam/
https://pay.albanna.sch.id/public/akun-pro-platinum/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-luar-negeri/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-thailand/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-kamboja/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-filipina/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-jepang/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-rusia/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-malaysia/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-macau/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-myanmar/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-vietnam/
https://pay.sekolahmutiara.id/baru/server-platinum/slot gacor 88slot gacor 4dslot gacor 777slot kambojaslot thailandslot hongkongslot platinumslot myanmarslot amerikaslot taiwanslot jepangslot malaysiaslot server luarmahjong slotsv388digmaansenang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99akun pro thailand
akun pro kamboja
akun pro jepang
akun pro rusia
akun pro hongkong
akun pro myanmar
akun pro malaysia
akun pro filipina
akun pro taiwan
akun pro vietnam
akun pro china
akun pro amerika
akun pro prancis
akun pro lebanon
akun pro platinum
akun pro ceko
akun pro yaman
akun pro korea
akun pro jerman
slot luar negeri
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot singapore
slot prancis
slot malaysia
slot korea
slot taiwan
slot dubai
slot eropa
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99
slot luar negeri
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot singapore
slot prancis
slot malaysia
slot korea
slot taiwan
slot dubai
slot eropa
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99akun pro amerikasenang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99akun gacor maxwin link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam akun pro jepangakun pro platinumakun pro thailandakun pro kambojaakun pro malaysiaakun pro taiwanakun pro myanmarakun pro vietnamakun pro hongkongakun pro filipinalive casino 77sv388digmaans128slot luar negeriakun pro jepangakun pro platinumakun pro thailandakun pro kambojaakun pro malaysiaakun pro taiwanakun pro myanmarakun pro vietnamakun pro hongkongakun pro filipinaakun pro amerikasenang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99slot taiwanslot malaysiaslot amerikaslot myanmarslot luar negerimahjong ways 2slot danasenang303sboku99spesial4dsukses303horus303amarta99slot server thailand slot server myanmar slot server kamboja slot server jepang slot server filipina slot server hongkong slot server china slot server malaysia slot server taiwan slot server ceko slot server dubai slot server prancis slot server italia slot server swiss slot server inggris slot server amerika slot 77 sv388 akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam casino online situs judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 slot 4d slot idn slot nuke akun slot link slot situs slot akun pro amerika akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro monaco akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam slot bca slot bri slot brilink slot bsi slot dana slot mandiri gates of gatot kaca x1000 gates of olympus x1000 starlight princes x1000 akun gacor link gacor situs gacor slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot luar negeri slot luar slot malaysia slot myanmar slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam senang303sbobetbola gacor 88slot danano limit citypragmatic slotslot pg softprincess x1000zeus 1000server taiwan 105senang303akun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro rusiaakun pro thailandakun pro malaysiaakun pro myanmarakun pro platinumakun-pro-hongkongakun pro taiwanakun pro amerikaakun-pro-filipinaakun-pro-koreaakun-pro-prancisslot gacor 88slot gacor 4dslot gacor 777slot kambojaslot thailandslot hongkongslot platinumslot jepangslot rusiaslot-server-kambojaslot-server-rusiaslot-server-jepangslot-server-jepangslot-server-malaysiaslot-server-thailandslot-server-taiwanslot-server-myanmarslot-server-vietnamslot-server-hongkongslot-server-filipinaslot-server-filipinaslot-server-singaporeslot-server-amerikaslot-server-amerikaslot-server-chinaslot-server-turkislot-server-ugandaslot-server-uruguayslot-server-mesirslot server amerikaslot server filipinaslot server hongkongslot server jepangslot server kambojaslot server koreaslot server malaysiaslot server prancisslot server rusiaslot server thailandslot server myanmarslot server vietnamslot server asiaslot server luarakun pro amerikaakun pro filipinaakun pro hongkongakun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro koreaakun pro malaysiaakun pro prancisakun pro rusiaakun pro taiwanakun pro thailandakun pro platinumakun pro singaporeakun pro vietnamslot thailand
slot pulsa
slot server luar
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot singapore
slot prancis
slot malaysia
slot korea
slot taiwan
slot dubai
slot eropa
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99slot gacor 88slot gacor 4dslot gacor 777slot kambojaslot thailandslot hongkongslot platinumslot myanmarslot amerikaslot taiwanslot jepangslot malaysiaslot server luarmahjong slotsv388digmaansenang303server thailand server myanmar server kamboja server jepang server filipina server hongkong server china server malaysia server taiwan server ceko server dubai server prancis server italia server swiss server inggris server amerika server slot 4d sv388 slot77 akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot gacor 88slot gacor 4dslot kambojaslot thailandslot hongkongslot platinumslot jepangslot rusiaslot taiwanslot malaysiaslot amerikaslot myanmarslot luarsenang303live casino 77sv388digmaans128slot luar negeriakun pro jepangakun pro platinumakun pro thailandakun pro kambojaakun pro malaysiaakun pro taiwanakun pro myanmarakun pro vietnamakun pro hongkongakun pro filipinaakun pro amerikasenang303slot server amerikaslot server filipinaslot server hongkongslot server jepangslot server kambojaslot server koreaslot server malaysiaslot server prancisslot server rusiaslot server thailandslot server myanmarslot server vietnamslot server asiaslot server luarakun pro amerikaakun pro filipinaakun pro hongkongakun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro koreaakun pro malaysiaakun pro prancisakun pro rusiaakun pro taiwanakun pro thailandakun pro platinumakun pro singaporeakun pro vietnamakun pro thailand
akun pro kamboja
akun pro jepang
akun pro rusia
akun pro hongkong
akun pro myanmar
akun pro malaysia
akun pro filipina
akun pro taiwan
akun pro vietnam
akun pro china
akun pro amerika
akun pro prancis
akun pro lebanon
akun pro platinum
akun pro ceko
akun pro yaman
akun pro korea
akun pro jermanslot server luar
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot singapore
slot prancis
slot malaysia
slot korea
slot taiwan
slot dubai
slot eropasenang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99akun gacor link gacor situs gacor slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot luar negeri slot luar slot malaysia slot myanmar slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam akun gacor akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro monaco akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro swiss akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam gates of gatotkaca x1000 gates of olympus x1000 starlight princess x1000 slot bca slot bni slot bri slot brilink slot bsi slot dana slot mandiri slot sakuku slot shopeepay akun pro rusia akun pro thailand akun pro swiss akun pro kamboja akun pro big855 akun pro malaysia akun pro taiwan akun pro myanmar akun pro amerika akun pro platinum slot deposit pulsa slot deposit pulsa tanpa potongan live casino 77sv388digmaans128slot luar negeriakun pro jepangakun pro platinumakun pro thailandakun pro kambojaakun pro malaysiaakun pro taiwanakun pro myanmarakun pro vietnamakun pro hongkongakun pro filipinaakun pro amerikasenang303slot luar negeri
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot singapore
slot prancis
slot malaysia
slot korea
slot taiwan
slot dubai
slot eropa
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99slot luar negeri
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot singapore
slot prancis
slot malaysia
slot korea
slot taiwan
slot dubai
slot eropa
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99akun pro jepangakun pro platinumakun pro thailandakun pro kambojaakun pro malaysiaakun-pro-rusiaakun pro amerikaakun-pro-filipinaakun-pro-hongkongakun-pro-koreaakun-pro-myanmarakun-pro-prancisakun pro taiwansenang303akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro monaco akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro swiss akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot myanmar slot platinum slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam slot bca slot bri slot bni slot dana slot edc slot mandiri slot 4d slot idnslot nuke akun slot link slot situs slot slot server amerikaslot server filipinaslot server hongkongslot server jepangslot server kambojaslot server koreaslot server malaysiaslot server prancisslot server rusiaslot server thailandslot server myanmarslot server vietnamslot server asiaslot server luarakun pro amerikaakun pro filipinaakun pro hongkongakun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro koreaakun pro malaysiaakun pro prancisakun pro rusiaakun pro taiwanakun pro thailandakun pro platinumakun pro singaporeakun pro vietnamsenang303akun pro jepangakun pro platinumakun pro thailandakun pro kambojaakun pro malaysiaakun pro taiwanakun pro jepangakun pro platinumakun pro thailandakun pro kambojaakun pro malaysiaakun-pro-rusiaakun pro amerikaakun-pro-filipinaakun-pro-hongkongakun-pro-koreaakun-pro-myanmarakun-pro-prancisakun pro taiwanslot taiwan slot thailand slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot luar negeri slot luar slot malaysia slot myanmar slot rusia slot singapore akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam live casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 slot 4d slot idn slot nuke akun gacor link gacor situs gacor slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot luar negeri slot luar slot malaysia slot myanmar slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam live casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 slot 4d slot idn slot nuke slot server amerikaslot server filipinaslot server hongkongslot server jepangslot server kambojaslot server koreaslot server malaysiaslot server prancisslot server rusiaslot server thailandslot server myanmarslot server vietnamslot server asiaslot server luarakun pro amerikaakun pro filipinaakun pro hongkongakun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro koreaakun pro malaysiaakun pro prancisakun pro rusiaakun pro taiwanakun pro thailandakun pro platinumakun pro singaporeakun pro vietnamakun pro jepangakun pro platinumakun pro thailandakun pro kambojaakun pro malaysiaakun-pro-rusiaakun pro amerikaakun-pro-filipinaakun-pro-hongkongakun-pro-koreaakun-pro-myanmarakun-pro-prancisakun pro taiwanslot luar negeri
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot singapore
slot prancis
slot malaysia
slot korea
slot taiwan
slot dubai
slot eropa
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99slot gacor 88slot gacor 4dslot gacor 777slot kambojaslot thailandslot hongkongslot platinumslot jepangslot rusiaslot taiwanslot malaysiaslot amerikaslot myanmarslot luar negerimahjong slotslot danasenang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99
slot dana
slot ovo
slot gopay
slot linkaja
slot seabank
slot bca
slot bni
slot bri
slot mandiri
slot bankjago
slot pulsaslot server thailand slot server myanmar slot server kamboja slot server jepang slot server filipina slot server hongkong slot server china slot server malaysia slot server taiwan slot server ceko slot server dubai slot server prancis slot server italia slot server swiss slot server inggris slot server amerika slot zeus slot88 sv388 slot server amerikaslot server filipinaslot server hongkongslot server jepangslot server kambojaslot server koreaslot server malaysiaslot server prancisslot server rusiaslot server thailandslot server myanmarslot server vietnamslot server asiaslot server luarakun pro amerikaakun pro filipinaakun pro hongkongakun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro koreaakun pro malaysiaakun pro prancisakun pro rusiaakun pro taiwanakun pro thailandakun pro platinumakun pro singaporeakun pro vietnamakun-pro-kambojaakun-pro-rusiaakun-pro-jepangakun-pro-malaysiaakun-pro-thailandakun-pro-taiwanakun-pro-myanmarakun-pro-vietnamakun-pro-hongkongakun-pro-filipinaakun-pro-singaporeakun-pro-amerikaakun-pro-chinaakun-pro-turkiakun-pro-ugandaakun-pro-uruguayakun-pro-mesirslot-server-kambojaslot-server-rusiaslot-server-jepangslot-server-malaysiaslot-server-thailandslot-server-taiwanslot-server-myanmarslot-server-vietnamslot-server-hongkongslot-server-filipinaslot-server-singaporeslot-server-amerikaslot-server-chinaslot-server-turkislot-server-ugandaslot-server-uruguayslot-server-mesirslot-server-kambojaslot-server-rusiaslot-server-jepangslot-server-malaysiaslot-server-thailandslot-server-taiwanslot-server-myanmarslot-server-vietnamslot-server-hongkongslot-server-filipinaslot-server-singaporeslot-server-amerikaslot-server-chinaslot-server-turkislot-server-ugandaslot-server-uruguayslot-server-mesirakun gacor link gacor situs gacor slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot luar negeri slot luar slot malaysia slot myanmar slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam live casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 slot 4d slot idn slot nuke slot server amerikaslot server filipinaslot server hongkongslot server jepangslot server kambojaslot server koreaslot server malaysiaslot server prancisslot server rusiaslot server thailandslot server myanmarslot server vietnamslot server asiaslot server luarakun pro amerikaakun pro filipinaakun pro hongkongakun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro koreaakun pro malaysiaakun pro prancisakun pro rusiaakun pro taiwanakun pro thailandakun pro platinumakun pro singaporeakun pro vietnamsenang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99
slot dana
slot ovo
slot gopay
slot linkaja
slot seabank
slot bca
slot bni
slot bri
slot mandiri
slot bankjago
slot pulsaakun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro amerika akun pro asia akun pro china akun pro filipina akun pro hongkong akun pro italia akun pro jepang akun pro jerman akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro lebanon akun pro london akun pro malaysia akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam live casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikan gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 slot 4d slot idn slot nuke slot luar negeri
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot singapore
slot prancis
slot malaysia
slot korea
slot taiwan
slot dubai
slot eropa
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99akun pro jepangakun pro kambojaakun pro rusiaakun pro thailandakun pro malaysiaakun pro myanmarakun pro platinumakun-pro-hongkongakun pro taiwanakun pro amerikaakun-pro-filipinaakun-pro-koreaakun-pro-prancisslot luar negeri
slot thailand
slot kamboja
slot filipina
slot jepang
slot rusia
slot belanda
slot china
slot hongkong
slot amerika
slot macau
slot myanmar
slot vietnam
slot singapore
slot prancis
slot malaysia
slot korea
slot taiwan
slot dubai
slot eropa
senang303
sukses303
horus303
spesial4d
sboku99
amarta99sbobetbola gacor 88slot danano limit citypragmatic slotslot pg softprincess x1000zeus 1000server taiwan 105akun gacor link gacor situs gacor slot amerika slot asia slot china slot dubai slot eropa slot filipina slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot luar negeri slot luar slot malaysia slot myanmar slot rusia slot singapore slot taiwan slot thailand slot vietnam akun pro amerika akun pro jepang akun pro kamboja akun pro korea akun pro malaysia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam slot amerika slot hongkong slot jepang slot kamboja slot korea slot malaysia slot singapore slot thailand live casino online judi bola resmi judi tembak ikangates of gatot x1000starlight princes x1000gates of olympus x1000slot 4dslot idnslot nukeakun gacorlink gacorsitus gacorakun pro amerikaakun pro filipinaakun pro koreaakun pro singaporeakun pro thailandakun pro vietnamslot 4d slot idnslot nukeslot amerika slot korea slot malaysia slot thailand slot vietnam gates of gatot x1000 starlight princes x1000 gates of olympus x1000 mahjong ways wild bandito akun gacor link gacor situs gacor akun pro myanmar akun pro platinum akun pro prancis akun pro rusia akun pro singapore akun pro taiwan akun pro thailand akun pro vietnam sbobetsboku99